Showing posts with label Talking Points. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Talking Points. Show all posts

Monday, April 25, 2016

5 Seriously Dumb Assertions About Copyright that John Degen thinks aren't dumb


You're a real dick, John.
Is this him? I think it's him.

One year ago, John Degen wrote an article on myths about copyright that media should stop repeating. When I read the headline I expected... something different.  Certainly not the most asinine, badly cobbled together, reductionist article about copyright I'd ever read, Now It's 9 in the morning, and I haven't had my breakfast, so if this article comes off as angry, it's because I am.

But before I get into dismantling this piece, I want to clarify that I am not an anti copyright person. I love copyright. Some of my best friends are copyrighted. But Copyright is all kinds of screwed up, and in dire need of reform. But anyway, tell me, Mr Degen, what are these myths you are talking about?

Myth #5. Artists Feel Restricted by Copyright

Artists don't feel restricted by copyright? Oh, ok.

You know that originally, George Lucas' plan before Star Wars was to make a new version of Flash Gordon, right? That was his idea. Instead, because of rights issues (which are going on to today, apparently, almost 40 years later), George Lucas instead did an original story only mostly ripping a lot of elements from Flash Gordon serials.

Now, you may point and say that that's a good thing, because we like Star Wars as it is. But imagine 10000s of George Lucases who saw a material decades their elder, realized that it was not available, and instead of making  a Star Wars, they made a nothing.

Even worst, when you consider that the artist today is also a fan. With the tools available to them the fan wants to make an X-Men fan series, a My Little Pony fighting game, and a remake of Streets of Rage made from scratch. It takes no business  away from Marvel, Hasbro, and Sega that these works exist. But still, in comes copyright law. Fuck you, George Lucas. You have to wait until the 2070's to be able to touch that Sega Game.


Myth #4. Copyright Harms the Public Domain


Myth #4. Night Harms Day.

Are you frickin' kidding me with that logic? Of course things being copyrighted keeps them out of the public domain!

But with that aside, what these half baked paragraphs gloss over is that our unreasonable copyright laws, it's created a dearth of new public domain works. Public Domain used to be like stuff your father had as a kid. Now it's  stuff from 100 years ago. To put it into perspective, when stuff does begin entering the public domain at all in 2019, it's gonna start with silent era movies and stuff like that. SILENT ERA. FROM ALMOST A CENTURY AGO!

"Secondly, can we please stop conflating copyright with a lack of access?"

You say. Books and film reels are finite. They can deteriorate over time, and carelessness. To people trying to preserve these works by duplicating them it's a pain to know they have to let it rot, lest the great grandson of the guy who  bought the rights to the film sue them because how dare you sir! I may not have even touched the property in 2 generations, but how dare you?

Myth #3. Copyright is an Attack on Artistic Freedom


It is. But it always wasn't.

You see, earlier iterations of Copyright law were merely about wholesale duplications of a work. For example, whole sale duplication of Huck and Finn? Illegal.  My own fan book where Huck is a pregnant naga and Finn a yiffy wolf? Acceptable. Because the heart of the law was that the duplication would undercut sales of the original, and thus the original author would thus have no reason to make MORE books. But we want more books, so we'll prevent that from happening.

But copyright grew in length and scope and with. Now it includes that you can't make a documentary about the song Happy Birthday because that song is copyrighted(that it isn't is a different issue.)

Now, you want to make your own Flash Gordon, even after it's public domain, and some guys take you to court before you even start filming.

And most heinously of all, the lenght of copyright was extended  for 40 years. Now, remember that I told you that copyright was supposed to incentivize the creation of works, right? So how does extending the copyright on a work do that? Bob Kane and Bill Finger created Batman for what is now DC in the 1940's. They did it to get payed THEN. When they heard the copyright (That wasn't their to begin with) on that was extended on the 70's, do you think they were incentivized to make even more stuff? "Well, old chum, I guess now that that copyright is longer on our old works is larger, we should really  get to work on doing more stuff".

So for no reason and against the heart of the law and the orders of the constitution, I can't  make my own Batman v Superman this year, when both characters would have been public domain  in the mid fuckin' 90's according to the law of their time.


Myth #2. Copyright Costs Consumers

Copyright costs consumers because copyright is a monopoly.

Monopolies generate hiked up prices due to lack of competition. Now, again, that's not all bad as long as Copyright is also doing the other stuff it's supposed to be doing. But how much is too much? Does the economy really need for the company that bought the company that had the rights to a film or book or song from the 40's, sell it  at for a 1341234020982058% profit margin? Or does the whole thing fall around our ears if they have to compete with other people also offering that same old timey ware?

Because a study found most works make most of their profit in the first 5 years. In fact, Congresses own study on copyright recommended that long long copyright isn't as helpful as "we think".

Myth #1. Copyright only helps Corporations
This isn't even a myth. It's real life. Even YOU admit it.

"Say what you want about large media corps, publishers, music and film companies, etc. — they’ve made way, way more of a tangible contribution to the livelihoods of the working artists I know than Google ever intends to."

The music industry is HORRIBLE with artists. Absolutely horrible. They sell a CD and pay the artist 1 cent. They sell a digital MP3 and pay the artist 0 cents. They put the artist's song in an ad and give the artist nothing. But they own the copyright, though. THESE are the people who want copyright to last forever.

The movie industry is so fucking shady with it's finances, they don't even know if movies are making money or not. They won't pay David Prowse, the man inside Vader's suit, because apparently Return of The Jedi never made it's money back {:(... THESE are the people who want copyright to last forever. THESE are the people living off of the works of others.

They always raise "the starving artists out there" when their humongous profits are threatened. And now that a digital age is here, where they aren't the only game in town anymore, where they can't control production and distribution and marketing, and where it doesn't take thousands of dollars and blowing  the right people to get in the door, they are scared. And they will do whatever it takes to keep a semblance of control. And copyright is one of those things.

They take the copyright laws THEY lobbied for, and abuse them. They'll lobby for international treaties that make copyright even more ridiculous, and then raise their hands and say "don't look at me, I didn't do it."


Copyright is like a penis. You've been led to think the longer it is, the better everything will be. And up to a certain point, longer is better than shorter. But there is a point where it's really not benefiting you anymore. What the Degens of the world haven't realized is that we're struggling to fit a 3 meter monster dong in this digital age's trowsers, when a reasonably sized one will not only do the job, but do it better. "Big ship, sailing be damned" is the saying in my country.

I can see were you're coming from: sometimes  when you see how people react to copyright, it can be a bit unsettling. But don't worry about copyright. It's already got entire transnational treaties enforcing it's ridiculous lenght. So no, it doesn't need you do defend it from the " ivory-tower legal-theory departments and digital-utopian advocacy group" meanies.

 See you in 95 years, hopefully.



Monday, May 11, 2015

Talking Points: The Starving Artist

You should have had your ears to the ground, buddy.

I get into plenty of comments sections discussing the topic of copyright.  You might be surprised, that some arguments start to form a pattern, and then I feel that, instead of replying to each and every one of those, I´d rather do a column adressing them.



For example, I´ve already seen at least two people bring this kind of talk :

"This is a bad era for artists! I spent so and so effort making an art, and then e'rebody stole it. You guys don't know what it's like to create something because you all want something for free!"

No, this wern't comments in videos and articles about "END COPYRIGHT FOREVER, FREE SHIT FOR EVERYBODY". These were comments in videos explaining in great detail how copyright was manipulated to do the entertainment industry's bidding.

I'd like to say all those guys are just People from the RIAA and MPAA sockpuppets  trying to change public opinion in their favor, but I have no evidence of that. In truth, piracy does affect a huge number of upstarts, which is most of the reason it exists. There may be people that legitimately feel those things, and I don't want to be patronizing to those people. But I have to disagree.
So this one's for you, Starving Artists. I'm gonna run you through a gamut of answers to your concerns.

A) It's not a battle of "All the copyright vs No copyright".

There are certainly those who feel copyright is an unnecessary element of law.  But people like Lawrence Lessig aren't those people. People like me aren't those people. We don't want copyright to  go away, we want it to do it's friggin' job. no more no less. It's job is giving artists a fighting chance in a world where duplication could ruin them.
Oh, look, a nice urinal


When we're discussing HOW copyright should be, it is wasteful to say "B-b-b-b-but copyright should exist." We know, baby, we know. Besides we already have some strong copyright and...

B)What happened to you  did not happen because not enough copyright.

 It's understandable to want the kinds of protections copyright promises (but can't actually enforce). But let's get serious here: Copyright lasts  more than the average human lives, and covers so many things it's not even funny.  In this world. This is the world where copyright reigns. There's not much more copyright out there to give.
I'm almost as old as copyright lasts!


If in THIS WORLD, your entire enterprise was taken down solely by pirates, then it is irrelevant to our discussion. In fact, yours is exactly the kind of work that should go public domain in a short time,  so that people could freely reuse it as they see fit. If you can't really make it in 10 years, you aren't likely gonna make it in 95 years. If you find that disheartening, maybe this will cheer you up.

C) Your project might have been doomed to failiure from the start.
If at first you don't succeed...you still got until 2082.



The world of art isn't a sure thing, buddy. For every artist that makes it and becomes well known and quoted, there are 30000 that nobody will ever know.

Perhaps your work wasn't good, perhaps it was not something that people would like, perhaps you didn't market yourself properly, or maybe you're just trying to make an outdated model work. Maybe it was too niche, or maybe too broad. Either way, your project just failed, as so many do.

But what's that got to do with stretching the copyright of works already made? The point of copyright is to inspire creativity, not hug every cat.

While anecdotally you may claim it was pirates, all loving your shit and not buying it, there's other people out there making money off of works. It might just be a personal failiure.

D)Many Other Starving Artists would like to use works under copyright, at some point, eventually.
See, Warner? You're the problem, not the solution.

Sure, from your stance I assume your works are entirely original, based solely on your own creative genius and gumption. And that's respectable. But it's not the only way to create art.

And that's part of it. Art building on other art. For example, next Summers Batman v Superman draw plenty of inspiration from Frank Miller's The Dark Knight Returns, which itself drew inspiration from decades of Batman comics. Is Zack Snyder NOT a lazy sack of shit for not coming up with his own thing instead just because the company he's working under owns the property? Coolio took Stevie Wonder Wonder Song and made it about Gangsters. Is he a lazy sack of shit for not coming up with his own thing? Smash Bros was going to not star known Nintendo characters. And I dare say we love it all the more BECAUSE they didn't come up with something new!

Well, there's someone out there who'd make a killer Batman/Superman comic. He doesn't have the money to pay for Warner's license(if they'd even let him), and he can't work there. Is he different from Zack Snyder?

Maybe someone out there is just starting in music, and has a great idea for a cover of Stevie Wonder's Superstitious. What's the difference between him and Coolio?

And maybe there's a breakaway game designer waiting to make a game reuniting the unsung heroes of defunct games from the 80s for a final game. Is he different from Nintendo, who knew that using popular characters instead of new ones would result in a more appealing (and profitable game)?


We've made existing works profitable enough to dominate the box offices and music charts for years, now. But that comes with an agreement that, you know, those works eventually  should become public domain. Hopefully  before 2019.




E) This companies don't care about you
I get royalties, they get the REAL Money.
Disney made Mulan. We say that, like Disney is a person, and Mulan is a chicken dinner. People made Mulan. Animators put effort into making the characters the Character Designers made move fluidly and with grace. Colorists gave it a beautiful pastel palette. A director whose name is not atop the movie's billboard guided the voice actors to express the emotions the scriptwriter wanted. And guess what? Most of those where only payed once.

Once the artists have built the centerpiece, Disney begins to build commercialism around it. Mulan toys which the character designer won't see any money from. Mulan Backpacks, which exploit the palette the colorists put into it, without liking it. And a live action remake, which the director, scriptwriters and actors who made the original likeable won't be getting paid for. And all this built around an old chinese poem from the public domain.

These laws aren't about you, guy who's trying to be an upstart. You're about as well covered as you're gonna get.  It's about THEM, enormous corporations who rule certain mediums and want to continue ruling them. They've been working together so long, they don't even understand the concept of  actually competing, and it fucking scares them.

So I hope this answered your questions. If you're gonna take away anything from this is that we need to seriosly look at our copyright, how works, what is it purpose, change the parts that aren't working. Is that so wrong?

Thursday, May 7, 2015

Talking points: Return the Stolen

YOU WOULDN'T STEAL A CAR. I mean, I assume. For all I know you might be a car thief of some sort. I wouldn't have any way of knowing, and frankly if the car does not belong to me and mine, I can't muster up any significant rage.

But we all remember that campaign, right? Where stealing  a handbag is exactly like having a movie's copy without paying for it? We had a good laugh  while we waited for these unskippable ads to get the hell out of our way and let us see our legal copy of District 9. After all, even if you don't know that the Supreme Court doesn't consider copyright infringment "theft" the differences between helping yourself to someone's only car and you having a movie which operates outside of the allowances of the owner is sufficiently large to give it some thought.


But what about the opposite? When early in the Year Boingboing reported on yet another sad Public Domain day, many objected to the title's assertion that these works had been "stolen" by the copyright extention.  After all, these works weren't YOURS or MINE to begin with.  What has been stolen.

Now, obviously  I don't know the true intent of the author. But hear me out.

You might yet have some older living relatives. If that is the case, you might be in for an inheritance. Effective following the death of said relative, you might be legally entitled to receive a benefit from that person.

Now, let's say that the inheritance is a sizable amount of money, held in a bank. This bank is earning interest from this money, and it is on it's best interest to keep the money where it is. So, after the reading of the will is done, you expect  the money to exchange hands. But the bank begins using trickery to delay you from getting your money. and they manage to keep the inheritance from actually ocurring for 40 years.

But it's not really YOUR money. It's just a money you where going to have, and well, the bank liked it, and had the means to keep it. Who are you to say the bank STOLE your inheritance? They might have robbed you of having what you legally(if not morally) deserve, but is that really stealing something from you?

Yes. Yes it it. It is immoral and unethical to undermine a legal transfer of goods. The entertainment industry might have "legally" convinced congress that copyrights on works then older than a generation needed  to remain under copyright more time, but that doesn't make it not stealing. They stole our inheritance, one that was going to benefit everyone.

 There are many rationalizations out there for the 76 extension and the Sonny Bono Act.  And if you want to believe them, go ahead and say that it's just a happy coincidence that the major beneficiaries from these laws are the people who spent millions of  dollars trying to get them passed. But all I see is a constitution disregarded, and a world where the prosumer remains bound by laws designed by consumer.

But maybe you disagree? If it's not stealing, what is it?

Never Forget

Never Forget

Popular Posts

Recent Posts

Unordered List

Text Widget

Recent Posts

Like us

About Me

My photo
I am NOT the Best Geek Ever. What I am is a Puerto Rican writer, drawing artist,artisan and all around geek slowly working my way up the web ladder.
Powered by Blogger.

Contact

Name

Email *

Message *